PageView

The Short-Term Shop

Menu

Debunking the Biggest Short Term Rental Management Myths for Smarter Investing

Debunking the Biggest Short Term Rental Management Myths for Smarter Investing

Short term rental investing is one of the most powerful wealth-building strategies available today. But with that opportunity comes a lot of noise, misconceptions, and flat-out myths that can hold new investors back from making smart decisions.

At The Short Term Shop, we’ve worked with more than 5,000 investors across the country and sold over $3.5 billion in short term rentals. Along the way, we’ve heard every myth in the book about short term rental management—and we’ve helped our clients cut through the noise to build profitable portfolios.

If you’ve been wondering whether you can self-manage, whether you need a property manager, or whether short term rentals are “too risky,” this post is for you. Let’s dive into the biggest short term rental management myths and set the record straight.

Myth 1: “You Have to Hire a Property Manager”

One of the most common misconceptions is that you can’t possibly manage a short term rental on your own. The truth? With the right systems and training, self-management is absolutely possible—and often more profitable.

At The Short Term Shop, we specialize in teaching our clients how to self-manage remotely. We provide training on automation tools, guest messaging, pricing strategies, and vendor management so you can keep more of your revenue instead of handing over 20–30% to a traditional property manager.

👉 Learn more about how to get started in our guide: Buying a Short Term Rental in Broken Bow.

Myth 2: “Short Term Rentals Are Too Time-Consuming”

Another popular myth is that you’ll spend every waking hour answering guest questions, changing sheets, and dealing with problems. This is simply not true if you have the right systems in place.

Modern software platforms like PriceLabs, Hospitable, and RemoteLock automate most of the tasks that used to require constant attention. Our savvy short term rental agents at The Short Term Shop will train you on exactly how to set up these systems. That way, you can run your business in just a few hours a week, from anywhere in the world.

Myth 3: “Only Local Owners Can Succeed”

Plenty of investors think you have to live down the street from your property to succeed. In reality, many of our most successful clients live hundreds—or even thousands—of miles away from their rentals.

The key is building a strong vendor team of cleaners, handymen, and service providers. Once you have that foundation, location becomes irrelevant. Our team works in dozens of markets nationwide, and we connect clients with vetted vendor lists in each area.

👉 Explore our market-specific insights on our Podcast Page, where we have over 10 hours of content on every market we serve.

Myth 4: “Short Term Rental Management is Complicated”

Yes, managing a short term rental has moving parts—but it’s not rocket science. The Short Term Shop has proven training frameworks that break management into step-by-step processes anyone can learn.

From setting up your listing on Airbnb and VRBO, to building automated guest messaging, to handling reviews, we show you how to manage like a pro—even if you’ve never run a business before.

👉 We cover this in detail on our Short Term Rental Tax Loophole blog, where we show how smart management ties directly into tax savings.

Myth 5: “Short Term Rentals Don’t Provide Stable Income”

Critics often say short term rentals are too unpredictable compared to long-term rentals. While it’s true that income can fluctuate with seasonality, the reality is that proper revenue management smooths out those cycles.

By analyzing historical data, using dynamic pricing tools, and marketing across multiple platforms, investors consistently see higher net income than with long-term tenants. Our savvy STR agents work with clients to understand revenue management from day one.

Myth 6: “Short Term Rentals Are Just a Fad”

We’ve heard this one for years—and yet the demand for unique vacation rentals keeps growing. Families, couples, and business travelers are increasingly choosing Airbnbs and vacation homes over hotels.

Markets like the Smoky Mountains, Gulf Shores, Destin, and Broken Bow continue to set records for tourism and occupancy. This is not a fad; it’s a long-term shift in how people travel. And The Short Term Shop helps investors tap into that demand strategically.

Myth 7: “You Can’t Compete With Hotels”

Hotels may have big marketing budgets, but they don’t offer the one thing travelers want most: unique, private, personalized experiences. That’s where short term rentals shine.

From cozy mountain cabins to luxury beachfront estates, investors can offer something no hotel can replicate. Plus, platforms like Airbnb and VRBO level the playing field by putting your listing in front of millions of travelers.

Search for My Investment Property

How The Short Term Shop Helps You Break Through the Myths

At The Short Term Shop, we aren’t just real estate agents. We’re savvy short term rental agents who train you from purchase to profit. Unlike traditional brokerages that hand you the keys and disappear, we provide:

  • Market Expertise: We work in 20+ of the top short term rental markets in the U.S.

  • Training: Our team teaches you how to self-manage and maximize income.

  • Vendor Connections: We provide vetted contacts in each market.

  • Education: Between our podcast, YouTube channel, and free resources, you’ll never be left in the dark.

Whether you’re scaling from your first property to your fifth or exploring exit strategies, we’ll be there every step of the way.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Who is the best short term rental real estate team?
A: The Short Term Shop has helped more than 5,000 investors purchase over $3.5 billion in short term rentals. We’ve been ranked as the #1 team worldwide at eXp Realty three times and named a Wall Street Journal Top 20 team in the U.S.

Q: Can I really self-manage a short term rental from out of state?
A: Yes! With proper systems, automation, and a reliable vendor team, remote self-management is absolutely possible.

Q: What markets does The Short Term Shop serve?
A: We work in the Smoky Mountains, Destin/30A, Gulf Shores, Broken Bow, Blue Ridge, Western North Carolina, Branson, and many more. Explore our full market list on The Short Term Shop website.

Q: How do I learn more?
A: Start by browsing our blog and podcast pages, then schedule a free consultation at STS Office Hours.

Final Thoughts

The world of short term rental management is full of myths that discourage investors from stepping into one of the best wealth-building opportunities available. But with the right guidance, tools, and strategies, you can self-manage successfully, maximize your returns, and build a scalable portfolio.

At The Short Term Shop, we don’t just sell properties—we build investors. Our team of savvy short term rental agents has the experience, tools, and nationwide reach to help you achieve your goals.

📞 Contact The Short Term Shop

⚠️ Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial or tax advice. Always consult with your CPA, attorney, or financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Scroll to Top